Many of you may have heard about this new "study" that says in 1 out of every 4 teenage girls in America has an STD
(Here's a link).

I heard about this yesterday, and my first thought was, "there is no way." And then, "There is no way that the information in that study is accurate. Someone's doing something illogical." I agree with Justin Taylor who remarked that when he was in junior high, lots of people bragged, but most people were still afraid to even
talk to someone of the opposite sex, much less do anything that put them in danger of an STD.
So this morning, I saw an article on the study in the Houston Chronicle, and I began my investigation. Here the important points I found:
1. The government did this study (first suspicious clue).
2. Gov. Rick Perry is citing this study as evidence why the state should FORCE all 12-year old girls (at least in public schools) to take a vaccination for cervical cancer (second suspicious, and sinister clue).
3. Planned Parenthood cites this study as evidence that abstinence-only education isn't enough. Of course, that's ridiculous. The problem isn't the education. The problem is that people aren't following it. If EVERYONE remained abstinent outside of marriage, then NOONE would have an STD (third suspicious clue).
And then I got to the big points that show this study for what it is.
1. This study was done in public clinics, you know, the kind that young teenage girls use when they're already having sex outside of marriage, and are wary about either being pregnant or having an STD.
2.
They tested only 838 girls. Yes, your read that right: 838. Just over 210 of the 838 had an STD. Of course, they say that
logically, this translates into 3 million teenage girls having STDs! There are an estimated 12 million teenage girls in this country! That means that they tested only .00006% of the population.
Allow me to quote from C.S. Lewis's
The Lion, The Witch, and the Wardrobe:
"Logic!" said the Professor to himself. "Why don't they teach logic at these schools?"

This study is a grand example of all things illogical. I have an idea. Why don't we do a test of our own, except our pool of teenage girls won't come from public clinics; it will come from those who stand outside of Planned Parenthoods praying and those who volunteer at Hope Pregnancy Centers. Then, if we find out that only 10 out of 838 have an STD, we can make a silly "logical" statement that only 1% of girls are infected.
I hope you enjoyed this rant on all things related to government studies, Planned Parenthoods, and ridiculous examples of illogic. If you ever want more, I'm sure I can think of something!